A review of seven published studies (Ernst 2010) states that “the most reliable clinical trials do not show any differences between flower remedies and placebos”. The validity of these results could be questioned, because clinical trial design inevitably distorts the way the Bach system is used, for example by giving all subjects a standard mixture instead of letting them take part in selecting their own combination of remedies. But in any case, considering that the remedies do help a majority of the clients seen in real life practice, does it really matter if they are “just placebo”?
Maybe it is time to replace the term “placebo” because of its negative connotations. At worst, it conjures up an image of dishonest charlatans charging fat fees for giving sugar pills to neurotic women with imaginary ills. But research has shown that a placebo element is involved in every intervention, including orthodox medical and surgical treatments as well as complementary and alternative therapies, and for “real” diseases as well as functional symptoms. By stimulating the body’s own self-healing capacity, with no risk of side effects, the placebo effect can be a powerful force for good.
Bach flower treatment could mobilise the placebo effect in several ways:
- Through deciding to explore a new therapy that is natural, gentle and pleasant to use, clients experience positive expectations and a sense of choice and control.
- Talking in a relaxed setting with a practitioner who is empathic and non-judgmental is therapeutic.
- Analysing specific negative emotions and attitudes according to the Bach system offers a new way of understanding problems.
- Taking the remedies four times daily provides a reminder of the positive feelings they are designed to instill.
Image: White Chestnut, a remedy for worrying thoughts.
One thought on “The placebo element in Bach flower therapy”
Thank you, Jennifer. Interesting to have attention drawn to the positive aspects associated with a placebo, and to remember that every medical or surgical intervention probably brings about some placebo effects.